Women's Health, Your Way

Ask & Search With Clara

Welcome to a new standard for women's health answers.

BODYTALK / The Feminine Urge to Volunteer (and Then be Shamed for It)

The Feminine Urge to Volunteer (and Then be Shamed for It)

The Feminine Urge to Volunteer (and Then be Shamed for It)

I grew up with a stay-at-home mom who used her privilege to help others. She didn't do paid work, but she worked unpaid shifts in soup kitchens, she organized to help refugees get on their feet, she cooked countless meals for our community center.

She did something we finally have a name for: Unpaid labor. A lot of it.

And according to much of the world, that's not good enough. I recently came across a podcast clip in which men were talking about how they'd feel about a woman who is "a catch" but is a volunteer worker and doesn't earn any money. Both men said they wouldn't be on board with this.

"I believe you should water your own grass first before you go and water someone else's," one man says.

And all I could think while watching this is..."well, easy for you to say."

Men, after all, have been raised to think about their own grass first. Women, on the other hand? We've been told in a million different ways that the things that make life worth living are the things we do for other people.

I believe people with the resources of time and money, the people who have theIr ability to donate their time, should do so. I also believe women are constantly exploited for their unpaid labor...whether within their own homes, or outside of them. And I can't really figure out where one thing ends and the other begins. Here's what I do know: Women aren't just the ones doing the unpaid work, we are also the ones doing the work of figuring out where exactly altruism bleeds into exploitation.

This is an issue worth examining: We were were raised to believe nobility was our ultimate calling. We were encouraged to go into "helping" professions. To put the work into our friendships and relationships and communities. We're expected to do this volunteer work, yet we're also expected to bring in fantastic incomes…and however we configure the balance, we’re told we aren’t doing enough. Enter: A millennial career crisis.

I don't see anyone shaming men for not volunteering for, say, their kids' field trips, but I do see people shaming women who "never show up for anything" all the time. Yet if you're a woman who does show up for everything, who chaperones the field trips and plans the neighborhood get-together and sits on the advocacy committee? Well, then it "must be nice" for you to "not have to work".

TL;DR? Volunteering is just another example of how we put women in impossible position after impossible position. We're shamed if we do, shamed if we don't. We're expected to do the unpaid work, plus the paid work too...and nobody ever stops to consider that there are only so many hours in a day.

More from BODYTALK

I can't seem to log on to social media without seeing content about the "millennial career crisis". It stands to reason: The job market is in shambles, everything is wildly... Read more
For the past six years, I've been living with a bit of a secret...and lot of anticipatory grief. I won't go into the details, because while I believe in talking... Read more
Years ago, when I was a writer for a major parenting magazine, an article by a colleague of mine made major waves. The gist of the article? It told us... Read more
So my entire TikTok feed is just clips from the Sports Illustrated Swim Week runway show.I’ve seen the Dancing With the Stars queens turning the runway into a dance floor.... Read more
Recently, I was chatting with a few friends about how stressful this particular season of life has been. We’re all moms of multiple kids who are navigating the wild thing... Read more
There’s still so much stigma surrounding surrogacy. There’s also so much mystery surrounding it…and in my opinion, those two things go hand in hand. In order to show surrogacy for... Read more
I will preface what I’m about to say with a disclaimer: I understand that sometimes people make jokes. I understand that comedy is about exaggeration. I understand that not everything... Read more
I was scrolling social media, as one does, when I came across a post from an influencer that made me physically roll my eyes. In the post, she begins with... Read more
On Mother’s Day this year, my husband did something I never thought anyone would do for me: He hit up our go-to sporting goods store (a place I've become very... Read more